sherwin williams alabaster white duck shoji natural choice oyster white paint colors

Design, Home

The 5 White Exterior Paint Colors we Tested

, , , ,

We have wanted a painted white brick home since three homes ago, and we finally took the plunge! Over the past few weeks, we’ve been trying out different tones of white paints and polling my IG buddies [HERE] to find the perfect (for us!) color. We wanted a saturated, creamy, warm white that felt like it could be found in nature as opposed to a cool or very bright white. White paint is so hard, you guys! We walked around our house and looked at samples forevvvverrrr, but we finally decided! Here are the 5 white exterior paint colors we tested, our observations about each one, and the final choice for our home!

alabaster oyster white duck shoji natural choice sherwin williams

Sherwin Williams – Alabaster

exterior paint colors alabaster sherwin williams

Source image: Mary Craven for Southern Living

Sherwin Williams Alabaster is my very favorite white to use on interiors, because it is a very neutral white that only slightly tips towards having warm undertones. Not too yellow, not too creamy…just right. It is a bright white with an LRV (light reflectance value) of 82, so it will definitely bounce the light around in space. Can’t recommend it enough for interiors to bring light into the space, but note that it is a very bright white for exterior where there is already a lot of light moving around.

Sherwin Williams – Oyster

Source image: Willow Homes via Houzz

Oyster white is darker that Alabaster on the scale, but just as creamy. It has lower LRV than Alabaster, and thus it didn’t read quite as bright, rather more like a very pale beige. We noticed hints of a green/grey undertone in some lights, and we really liked the richness of the color. If you are wanting to lean over into a pretty warm white, Oyster would be a good pick!

Sherwin Williams – Natural Choice

natural choice exterior white paint color

Source image: Homebunch

Natural Choice is another creamy, warm white color with a light reflectance value of 73, thus similar in brightness to Oyster. Neither bounce off nearly as much white as Alabaster, so if you are looking for a deep, non-stark white, this is a good pick! We noticed that the undertones of Natural Choice stayed pretty neutral with a beige or slightly peach hue underneath the white tones, and it didn’t lean too cool or too green/grey in the sunlight. This color feels like a white you’d find in nature, for sure, rather than coming across as stark or too cold.

Sherwin Williams – Shoji White

Source image: Peppeard Design

Shoji White was one of my favorites at first, because it has a tiny bit of a pink undertone to it, almost like the inside of a shell only whiter. It’s a very creamy, very pale greige-white with an LRV of 74, although surprisingly it felt just as bright as Alabaster. I would love to use this on an interior room and then use blush pinks and pretty peach tones to pull that hue out even more. It’s truly like the inside of sea shell like my neighbor said!

Sherwin Williams – White Duck

best white paint for exterior

Source image: Plank and Pillow

White Duck is like the perfect middle between Alabaster and Shoji, in our opinion. It has a light reflectance value of 73.5, so definitely not as bright as Alabaster. It also is very creamy like Shoji but has a neutral undertone to it, rather than the pink in Shoji. If I wanted a bright-but-not-too-bright creamy white color that didn’t lean too beige or warm, this would be a great color!

sherwin williams alabaster white duck shoji natural choice oyster white paint colors

In the end, we went with….Natural Choice (along with Dorian Gray for trim/garage)! In our lighting during different times of the day, it stayed the truest in color, it wasn’t too bright or too yellow, and it felt like a white you’d actually see out in nature! Can’t wait to update this post with finished product photos soon, and I hope the 5 exterior white paint colors that we tested on our home prove helpful to you, too!

share this post on



leave a comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Jenni Thomas says:

    Thank you for this, it’s so very helpful! I never new there were so many white paint colors with different tones until we bought a house last year and went to Sherwin Williams. 😳 ThankS for doing the hard work for us❤️❤️❤️

  2. Cari says:

    Love These colors!! I can’t believe how whites are so different!! Love what you choose!! I also want everyone of those homes as my own as well!! So adorable!!

  3. meg says:

    THis was super helpful. my walls are covered in so many swatches right now and white is indeed the hardest.
    Do you have pics of the exterior updated with natural choice? curious to see/hear the update

  4. It is a wonderful article stating about the topic in detail.This article is very helpful. This article mentions and acts as such a moving trigger. It is an article worth applauding for based on its content. This is a great post; I will share as much as I can. Well, I have visited another site hoangbachpainting.nz having some wonderful and similar information.

  5. Hope Williams says:

    THe Colors are Beautiful! I am in love with the white duck color and the house trim. Do you know what shades were used for the trim? THanks so much!!!

  6. Becky says:

    Did you use Natural choice as is or cut it down?

  7. olga says:

    this was very helpful to me, as i am building a new home and deciding on paint colors. I couldn’t see the difference between shoji white and white duck before. so This was insightful. Great looking post btw.

  8. This so interesting and informative post for all peoples who wants to know about white exterior paint colors. Thanks for sharing such great information with us.

  9. Jen Howell says:

    I can’t seem to find a pic on your blog of the finished exterior color. We are getting ready to paint our brick and natural choice is my top contender. I’d love to see your house!!

  10. […] Natural Choice is another creamy, warm white color with a light reflectance value of 73, thus similar in brightness to Oyster. via […]

  11. […] Natural Choice is another creamy, warm white color with a light reflectance value of 73, thus similar in brightness to Oyster. via […]

  12. […] Natural Choice is another creamy, warm white color with a light reflectance value of 73, thus similar in brightness to Oyster. via […]

  13. Samantha Wasinger says:

    I have missed you! I’m looking through Pinterest at painting our brick house white and ran into your post!!!! Do you have updated pictures since painting your house white, Or a page I can see it!! I have kept you & your family in my prayers every since you said good bye on Insta!! Hope all is well!!!♥️

  14. Laura says:

    Can you share the window trim and door color on the house with the white duck exterior? Its the last house pictured. Thank you

  15. Stefanie Garrett says:

    Do you have updated exterior photos? I’m considering g Natural Choice for mine and would love to see yours!

close menu



browse by topic


My home

learn how to make a DIY embroidery wreath

Erin's Guide 


vintage love




browse by topic



Baking with kids

Erin's Guide 


close menu



browse by topic

wardrobe capsules

style favorites

wardrobe capsules

Erin's Guide 

style try ons

close menu



browse by topic

beauty capsules


Beauty capsules

Erin's Guide 

close menu



browse by topic

on motherhood

kid projects

on finding rest in the midst of motherhood

Erin's Guide